Welcome, visitor!   Register   Login

Post an Ad
Menu Post an Ad

Pipeline Activism: Thoughts On My Trial, Part 2

    Health & Wellness, Indigenous News, News & Events    March 18, 2019

I’m back from the rabbit hole of court – the B.C. Supreme Court, in downtown Vancouver. Last fall, I spent five days there, self-representing my not guilty plea, after arrest for protesting on March 23rd in front of Texas oil-giant Kinder Morgan’s tank farm in Burnaby, now Trans Mountain Canada, owned by all Canadians. Three others are being tried with me, arrested on different days, represented by lawyers.

We didn’t finish last fall, so resumed on March 12th, taking another day and a half to close my case. On May 1st, the judge will phone me to give his verdict. If guilty, as he’s found to date for nearly all arrestees, nearly 240 total, I’ll return to court for sentencing.

I entered this strange world with such naiveté. The Alice in Wonderland feeling starts with remembering how professionally I thought the RCMP behaved throughout the protest, as if their respectful treatment of protesters would be matched by legal competency. Failing that, I thought they’d bear the consequences, but through my trial, I’ve learned differently.

The nub of my case concerns my actus rea, or guilty actions, and mens rea, or guilty mind, i.e. my intention to break the law. The Crown contends that I engaged in a prohibited action in a prohibited area, and that I intended to do both.

Their job is to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that I meant to obstruct Trans Mountain (TM) traffic, and that I recklessly did so. I know, absolutely, that I did neither. To keep my protest lawful, I did my best to stay off TM property and out. the 5-metre injunction zone. I would have let any traffic, of any sort, pass, although there was none, because the police had blocked it, out of sight. I was cautious and careful, taking about 5 hours to get clear on the ground rules.

While Alice in Wonderland grew and shrunk in size, I’ve stayed my same small self throughout all this. What’s gotten larger and smaller around me are key legal tenets I thought existed and had counted on.

The biggest revelation is that the “mistakes in law” made by TM and the RCMP, which misled me to believe I was on public property when I was not, are all on me. They bear no responsibility. The law as written – the Injunction Order, in my case – supercedes their sloppy implementation of it, meaning I needed to be more expert than they were, in every detail and operation.

I also used to think that if I was doing something illegal, in an illegal place, for hours on end, with a large number RCMP officers standing by and watching, they would let me know, in some manner, that I was breaking the law. Uh uh. The police have no obligation to tell protesters where the no-go zones are, to block entry to them, or to warn trespassers that they risk arrest.

If, through RCMP mistakes and oversight, one is misled, as I was, into a prohibited area, to the point that they say, “Move, or we’ll arrest you,” the only way to prove a mind free of guilt and recklessness is to move.

I stayed put, to uphold my right to an allowed action – peaceful, safe, lawful protest, a cornerstone of Canadian democracy – in an allowed area – obviously a public road end with a public pathway crossing it. Through RCMP actions, I was certain where the property line and arrest zone were, which I stayed away from, a certainty confirmed in their written and oral testimony.

The real Wonderland kicker, as I see it, is that refusing to move has become proof of my intention to break the law, because if I hadn’t intended to break the law, then I would have moved. The situation seems like entrapment, cinched with a neat Catch 22.

What was in my mind as a result of TM and the RCMP mistakes in law is irrelevant. What should have been in my mind based on the law as it’s written, not as it was faultily administered, is what matters.. It’s all loopy, and if one loop doesn’t point to a guilty verdict, then another one does.

I hope that the judge can peer well enough into my mind to see a reasonable doubt of guilt. If not, then justice, such as it is, will be built on a nice bit of post hoc ergo propter hoc, meaning, in my case, that, “after this action in this place, therefore because of this intention.”

We’ll see. In the meantime, all of these protests are very old news, lost in yesteryear. When the construction of the Trans Mountain pipeline resumes, however, after P.M. Trudeau’s cabinet approves it in a few months, the public protests will begin again and get more serious, as the stakes escalate. More naive protesters will then fall into the legal rabbit hole. Maybe circulating a heads-up like this will help organizers better inform protesters about how the legal system actually works.

Read More: Thoughts on My Arrest and Thoughts on my Trial

Comments May Not Be Seen by the Author

No Tags


Post an Event

Community News

  • Island Pathways Receives $18,500

    by on 7 hours ago

    Last Wednesday evening, 100+ Women Who Care Salt Spring Island gathered in the ArtSpring theatre for its third meeting. And something interesting happened… One of the three charities randomly drawn during the meeting, from the 18 that had been nominated, had been drawn before but hadn’t been voted to receive the funds. Back into the […]

  • Winter Cabbage, Irrigation Tips, Beet Le...

    by on May 20, 2019

    From now on, continue to be alert for heat waves and be prepared to shade seedbeds and seedlings and to mulch plants to cool the soil. The heat wave earlier this month resulted in injury to unprotected seedlings that is showing up now. Heat injury appears as white or biscuit coloured patches on leaves; whole […]

  • Salt Spring Island Fire Rescue Respond t...

    by on May 17, 2019

    Salt Spring Island Fire Rescue responded to an early morning structure fire in the 100 blk of Thomas Road. The initial call came in at 04:37 and crews completed the scene at 08:00. 25 Firefighters responded with 19 on scene; 4 fire trucks and 3 support vehicles along with BC Ambulance and BC Hydro. On […]

  • $1.5 Million Approved for First Stage of...

    by on May 16, 2019

    The Lady Minto Hospital Foundation has approved $1.5 million in initial funding for the proposed Lady Minto Hospital Emergency Department expansion and redevelopment project. Members of the Hospital Foundation voted at a special general meeting May 16, 2019 to fund the proposed project’s schematic design and design development stages, “This is an important step forward […]

  • Increasing Cost of Fuel Leads BC Ferries...

    by on May 16, 2019

    BC Ferries is advising customers that due to current fuel market conditions, the company will implement a fuel surcharge of 1.5 per cent on June 1. BC Ferries closely monitors the cost of fuel and applies a rebate or surcharge, or neither, under a regulatory process that is independent of fares. Here is an example […]

  • Growing Community Concern about Legion R...

    by on May 15, 2019

    A week before the April 30th Salt Spring Local Trust Committee meeting, islanders learned that a 144-foot tall Capital Region Emergency Service Telecommunications (CREST) radio tower was in the final stages of approval for construction at the Legion in Ganges, and that 4G and eventually 5G cellular antennas would likely be added to this tower. […]

  • Tofino Mayor Josie Osborne visits Salt S...

    by on May 15, 2019

    If you’ve been to Tofino in the last couple of years you will know that it’s a cool place. Not only are the beaches and the surfing and the mountains excellent, but the community looks to be thriving. Local government clearly has done well, not only in fostering a strong economy, but also at preserving […]

  • History of the Salt Spring Island Golf C...

    by on May 14, 2019

    March 23, 1928, saw a public meeting at Mahon Hall. Thirty-three people attended with the intention of forming a golf club. With W.E. Scott in the chair, K. Butterfield undertook secretarial duties. It was announced that a committee which had been appointed by the Salt Spring Island Development Association had been exceedingly busy. ‘Barnsbury’, the […]

  • Extensive Vandalism to Local CRD Office ...

    by on May 12, 2019

    In the morning of May 12, 2019 the Salt Spring RCMP were notified that a number of the street-front windows in Ganges, including the CRD office on McPhillips Ave had been smashed.  Police attended and their investigation is ongoing.  No entry was gained to the office, and efforts are underway to repair the damage prior […]

Pin It on Pinterest