Welcome, visitor!   Register   Login


Post an Ad
Menu Post an Ad

Electoral Reform Ballots in the Mail

    Editorial & Opinions, Governance & Politics    October 24, 2018

Does our electoral system need changing? Andrew Coyne has argued it most certainly does: “Anyone who ever proposes to change anything inevitably runs into the unanswerable objection that this would mean… changing things. Nowhere is this more true than with regard to electoral reform. […] At some point someone invariably invokes that ancient bit of cornpone philosophy: ‘If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it’, which is very good advice unless it is broke.”

He continued, explaining why our current system is less than democratic – often, majority governments are formed with less than 40% of the popular vote. For democracy to work, people need to be free to vote for the candidate and party of their choice. But under our system, fear of splitting the vote means people are told, “you can’t vote for the party you prefer, but must vote for a party you don’t like to prevent a party you detest from getting in.”

Canada’s democracy has evolved over the years, sometimes to improve democracy, but other times, not so much. It wasn’t until 1918 that women were allowed to vote federally, and not until 1960, that indigenous people with status were given that right. In BC, in 1952, the then Liberal-Conservative coalition government went ahead, without a referendum, to change from the First Past the Post system we have now to an alternative vote (AV) system. An article in The Star argues this was done to prevent the CCF (the forerunner to the NDP) from taking power. In 1953 the Social Credit party won a majority under this system, then switched back to FPTP and stayed in power until 1972.

Fast forward to 2004. Eight years earlier, an NDP majority government had been elected even though the NDP had fewer votes overall than the Liberals. Then Premier Gordon Campbell established a Citizens Assembly, composed of randomly selected citizens from all across the province. They voted 146 to 7 in favour of a proportional electoral system for BC. Their preferred system was the BC-STV but the legislation required at least 60% support for it to pass. With 57.7% support, the referendum failed.

Opponents of BC’s current electoral reform process, including the Independent Contractors and Business Association (ICBA) and the Canada West Construction Union went to court to stop the process but were unsuccessful. The no side has also produced ads that make false allegations. Fairvote Canada BC produced the https://prorepfactcheck.ca site to counter these false claims.

Now it is our turn. Everyone registered to vote should be receiving a mail-in ballot in the next week or two. The ballot is valid even if you only answer one question, but it needs to be returned to Elections BC by the end of November.

Comments May Not Be Seen by the Author

No Tags

  

Post an Event

Community News

  • Country Grocer Starting a Free Saturday ...

    by on 8 hours ago

    Country Grocer will be starting a FREE Saturday shuttle this weekend May 25th. The free shuttle will run from 9:30am – 3:30pm between Centennial Park, Rainbow Road Pool and Country Grocer. Sandwich boards will be placed at pick up locations with the pick up at Centennial Park being located in the “no parking on Saturdays” […]

  • Island Pathways Receives $18,500

    by on May 22, 2019

    Last Wednesday evening, 100+ Women Who Care Salt Spring Island gathered in the ArtSpring theatre for its third meeting. And something interesting happened… One of the three charities randomly drawn during the meeting, from the 18 that had been nominated, had been drawn before but hadn’t been voted to receive the funds. Back into the […]

  • Winter Cabbage, Irrigation Tips, Beet Le...

    by on May 20, 2019

    From now on, continue to be alert for heat waves and be prepared to shade seedbeds and seedlings and to mulch plants to cool the soil. The heat wave earlier this month resulted in injury to unprotected seedlings that is showing up now. Heat injury appears as white or biscuit coloured patches on leaves; whole […]

  • Salt Spring Island Fire Rescue Respond t...

    by on May 17, 2019

    Salt Spring Island Fire Rescue responded to an early morning structure fire in the 100 blk of Thomas Road. The initial call came in at 04:37 and crews completed the scene at 08:00. 25 Firefighters responded with 19 on scene; 4 fire trucks and 3 support vehicles along with BC Ambulance and BC Hydro. On […]

  • $1.5 Million Approved for First Stage of...

    by on May 16, 2019

    The Lady Minto Hospital Foundation has approved $1.5 million in initial funding for the proposed Lady Minto Hospital Emergency Department expansion and redevelopment project. Members of the Hospital Foundation voted at a special general meeting May 16, 2019 to fund the proposed project’s schematic design and design development stages, “This is an important step forward […]

  • Increasing Cost of Fuel Leads BC Ferries...

    by on May 16, 2019

    BC Ferries is advising customers that due to current fuel market conditions, the company will implement a fuel surcharge of 1.5 per cent on June 1. BC Ferries closely monitors the cost of fuel and applies a rebate or surcharge, or neither, under a regulatory process that is independent of fares. Here is an example […]

  • Growing Community Concern about Legion R...

    by on May 15, 2019

    A week before the April 30th Salt Spring Local Trust Committee meeting, islanders learned that a 144-foot tall Capital Region Emergency Service Telecommunications (CREST) radio tower was in the final stages of approval for construction at the Legion in Ganges, and that 4G and eventually 5G cellular antennas would likely be added to this tower. […]

  • Tofino Mayor Josie Osborne visits Salt S...

    by on May 15, 2019

    If you’ve been to Tofino in the last couple of years you will know that it’s a cool place. Not only are the beaches and the surfing and the mountains excellent, but the community looks to be thriving. Local government clearly has done well, not only in fostering a strong economy, but also at preserving […]

  • History of the Salt Spring Island Golf C...

    by on May 14, 2019

    March 23, 1928, saw a public meeting at Mahon Hall. Thirty-three people attended with the intention of forming a golf club. With W.E. Scott in the chair, K. Butterfield undertook secretarial duties. It was announced that a committee which had been appointed by the Salt Spring Island Development Association had been exceedingly busy. ‘Barnsbury’, the […]

Pin It on Pinterest