Welcome, visitor!   Register   Login

Post an Ad
Menu Post an Ad

Incorporation: CRD Director Wayne McIntyre Weighs In

    Editorial & Opinions, Governance & Politics    September 2, 2017

The Salt Spring Island governance referendum vote will be held on September 9th. The two options will be to remain with the status quo or to move to a municipal model. Many have asked for my opinion, which I believe is appropriate to share. My experience in local government is extensive and I believe as a politician on Salt Spring is unique. I have had first- hand experience as an elected local politician in both systems of local governance, first as a municipal councillor in the Village of Lions Bay and second as a two term Electoral Area Director for Salt Spring Island. I also have had decades of experience in various capacities in both provincial and municipal governance matters.

I will be voting yes and will give a few very specific examples of why. Most will agree that the most effective governance models have a structure appropriate for their community and elected officials who support moving their community priorities forward .In addition, crucial to effective local government are strategic planning, priority setting, local decision making, centralized and overarching financial planning and service support.

Our current governance model has serious weaknesses in all of these areas. Three of the largest budgets impacting the Salt Spring taxpayer are the CRD, Islands Trust and the Fire Department. Sadly Salt Spring Island doesn’t have a comprehensive, multi-disciplinary strategic plan and the present system of budgeting and financial planning for Salt Spring is done in silos. As an example the CRD and Islands Trust have local government oversight but the Fire Department does not as the process is led by a Board elected only by property owners, disenfranchising many residents. The latter is also an Improvement District and not eligible for senior government funding for capital projects. None of the main budgets affecting the SSI taxpayer are prioritized, reviewed and agreed to in concert, i.e. between the CRD, Islands Trust and the Fire Department and decision making is fractured and teamwork limited.

The CRD budget is driven by service requirements with separate budgets, and approval by a 24 person Board of Directors is required, with only one Board member from Salt Spring. All these budgets are set and managed separately. In the municipal model individual budgets are set, approved and managed by a locally elected council with oversight responsibility and local, open meetings. Municipal revenues are considered in most cases general revenue and if circumstances change it is possible to consider moving money to a different budget centre or centres, unlike in our present model. The present system is complex, inflexible and formal oversight is off island.

Support for Salt Spring services is split between resources on Salt Spring for infrastructure such as waste management, CRD water districts, parks and recreation services. While we have successfully provided more resources on island with a local CRD Senior Manager and an on-island Engineer, we still have a heavy dependency on CRD headquarters resources and bear the costs when this support comes to SSI as three hours plus of travel time for each is included in the SSI service billings. I should qualify that by saying that, CRD headquarters provides some great support- when we can get it- but integrating more service support resources, including administration, on Salt Spring rather than in Victoria would build a stronger team and be more effective.

SSI governance weaknesses need to be addressed using a proven model for a community of our size. The choice is now up to the Salt Spring voters. Focus on the facts and review the material contained on the website http://www.latest.incorporationstudy.com above all please vote, it is our future, help define it.

Wayne McIntyre, Electoral Area Director Salt Spring Island

Editors Note: This rationale for this opinion was added to the story to give context to why/how the original piece was submitted.

Along with others, particularly the SSI Trustees and the two committees we selected , I have been involved with the two SSI studies for over five years; the first the comparison of our present governance system with the municipal model and the second a full incorporation review, including financials. The Trustees and I were stewards of the two studies and this process was completed with the delivery of the final study to the ministry on November 21, 2016; at that time the Incorporation Committee was disbanded thereby ending the formal process.

The three of us provided support as follow up to the end of the formal process and one significant commitment was made, which was completed on August 30th: the debates with three representatives on each side. With the increasing pressures to say something as an elected representative of the community and the number of statements made that were confusing or in some cases incorrect, I felt I could ad value to the process. This was based on my direct involvement with municipalities as an elected municipal councillor, community volunteer and a contractor covering decades, along with two terms as the SSI Electoral Area Director. It is not uncommon in BC for local government elected officials to give personal views on matters important to their community.

Before I presented my view, I discussed the matter with the CRD Corporate Officer and there was no issue for me to express as a personal opinion. Based on feedback a significant majority have thanked me for my insight.

Comments May Not Be Seen by the Author

No Tags


Community News

  • Podcast: The Tiny Home on Wheel’s ...

    by on July 8, 2019

    I’m on the Salt Spring Gulf Island Community Radio interviewing people near and far who are making good news on the planet by helping to shift the outcome of our future. These people and companies have created solutions to local and global issues we’re facing at the moment. Sharing the good news that’s happening on […]

  • Carrot Day

    by on July 5, 2019

    It is time for my annual reminder to sow lots of carrots for winter harvests in the next week or two. For me, July 1 is always Carrot Day as well as Canada Day (US readers: think 4th of July). As long as you sow before July 10, your carrots should have time to grow […]

  • Minister Seeking Input on Private Manage...

    by on July 3, 2019

    Minister wants your input on future of British Columbia forests – On May 28, 2019, the provincial government announced a review of the Private Managed Forest Land Program. They have invited British Columbians to add your voice to the program review. The province is accepting public comments until July 22, 2019. Over the past few […]

  • 2019 Eco Living and Home Tour: Ideas, In...

    by on July 3, 2019

    Headlines announcing biodiversity collapse and climate catastrophe can feel paralyzing. Even the most committed environmentalists may not know where to turn for solid information on the kinds of innovative — and dramatic — lifestyle changes that experts say will be need to weather the coming changes. Salt Spring’s Eco Living and Home Tour highlights what […]

  • BC’s Rural Islands Launch Economic Forum...

    by on June 27, 2019

    For the first time BC’s rural islands have launched an initiative to cultivate rural island economic partnerships. The Rural Islands Economic Forum (RIEF), a two day event, will bring together leaders from rural island communities to focus on advancing local and regional, sustainable, economic capacity building. The Forum gets underway on Pender Island on November 7 […]

  • Survey: Should British Columbia Adopt Ye...

    by on June 24, 2019

    British Columbians are invited to share their views on how we should observe time in our province. Most areas of B.C. currently “spring forward” into Daylight Saving Time during summer months and “fall back” to Standard Time in the winter. The following choices are being considered: 1) B.C. continues the practice of changing our clocks […]

  • Podcast: Adam Olsen speaks with Raffi – ...

    by on June 20, 2019

    When I first thought of transitioning my weekly Public Circle LIVE! broadcasts from Facebook to a weekly podcast, I had it in my mind to invite Raffi as a guest. We have run into each other a few times now at the Salt Spring Island Saturday Market and I appreciate his forthright political commentary on Twitter. It all […]

  • Fire News: Chief’s Response Report – 201...

    by on June 20, 2019

    Vision: A responsive and sustainable fire-rescue service, effectively meeting community needs and valued by those we serve. Mission: Always learning, engaging and adapting to be response ready. Response Report Salt Spring Island Firefighters responded to 61 calls for assistance in May.  (Calls to Date:  291) Operations To be proactive regarding wildfire prevention a recommendation was […]

  • Salt Spring Foundation Announces 2019 Ne...

    by on June 18, 2019

    The Salt Spring Island Foundation, in partnership with Salt Spring Island Community Services, is pleased to announce the recipients of our 2019 Neighbourhood Small Grants. The Neighbourhood Small Grants program offers grants of $50 to $500 to support projects that bring people together, share skills and knowledge, build a sense of community belonging and responsibility, […]

  • Island Youth Soccer Association to Build...

    by on June 14, 2019

    Salt Spring Island Youth Soccer Association (SSIYSA) is excited to announce that School District #64 (SD64) has agreed to partner with the SSIYSA to build a brand-new all-weather turf field with lights at the Gulf Islands Secondary School (GISS) lower field. An All Weather Field Feasibility Study was presented to the SD64 school board yesterday […]

  • Salt Spring Island Foundation Announces ...

    by on June 12, 2019

    The Salt Spring Island Foundation is pleased to announce over $148,000 in spring grants for local charities, including $30,000 targeted to youth recreation programs. The Foundation thanks the many generous donors who make these grants possible.  BC Parks/Friends of Ruckle Park Heritage To create and install six new interpretive signs for Ruckle Provincial Park to […]

Pin It on Pinterest